|
|
|
Home::Charlie Cook
The Cloning Debate
Author : Peter Kennedy
Cloning is the process of creating an exact copy of the original, and recently, “cloning” refers to the replication of living humans and animals. Somatic cell nuclear transfer, as the process is called, involves removing the nucleus from an egg cell and replacing it with the nucleus from a cell of the organism to be cloned. In the past few years, advances have been made in both human and animal cloning. Scottish scientists famously cloned a sheep, and British scientists reportedly cloned a human embryo that survived for five days. Cloning is an extremely controversial subject that forces society to examine the proper limits of man’s control over life.
In 1997, Scottish scientists famously produced a female sheep, “Dolly,” using the process of reproductive cloning. Since that time, other scientists have cloned other species, including cows and rabbits. Most recently, scientists are attempting to reproduce humans through cloning. President Bush and the Republican party are strongly in opposition to human cloning. Conservatively tend to believe that life is a creation, “not a commodity,” and that human cloning would have a disastrous impact on the American moral fabric. In 2002, Congress introduced a bill that would ban human cloning in all forms, imposing a prison sentence and multi-million dollar fine on anyone who attempted human cloning. (The Ban on Human Cloning Act has yet to be passed.)
There are practical considerations to the cloning debate, as well. Most medical experts believe that reproductive human cloning would not produce a health newborn. Indeed, many scientists predict that cloning would produce harmful abnormalities in a baby’s genes. Many scientists and medical practitioners welcome the advance of cloning for individual human cells. This process, called therapeutic cloning, adopts the concept of cloning on a micro scale, to help regenerate broken or diseased body parts. Some politicians, such as Republican Senator Arlen Spector of Pennsylvania, support the idea of therapeutic cloning.
Critics of therapeutic cloning argue that the process should be prohibited, no matter how beneficial the practical applications may turn out to be. The most vocal critics of therapeutic cloning, mainly from religious communities, argue that the destruction of human life, even on cellular level, is a moral offense. These cells form the beginning of human life, and humans do not have the right to destroy life in order to create life. The creation of life, they argue, should be left to God.
The cloning debate lends itself to larger questions, including: Is it immoral to recreate life artificially? Does human life really begin at the cellular level? Should the government interfere with scientific advances that could benefit millions of people?
About the author:
OpineTree is a blog website that encourages debate on today’s most controversial political topics, including abortion, affirmative action, http://www.opinetree.com/cloning.html">cloning, the death penalty, euthanasia, gay marriage, gun control, health care, social security, stem cells, as well as other http://www.opinetree.com”>debate topics. Visit http://www.opinetree.com/cloning.htmlto join the http://www.opinetree.com/cloning.html">cloning debate.
Related articles
|
More related feeds |
UNESCO Advises UN to Re-Open Cloning Debate
The International Bioethics Committee (IBC) will gather in Paris to “explore whether the scientific, ethical, social, political and legal developments on human cloning in recent years justify a new initiative at international level, ...The Ethics of Cloning
So as a legal issue stem cell research and embryonic research is more widely tolerated than outright cloning, but even with that being said it still being disputed widely and different governments have different standards in relation to ... FROM LOUISE BROWN TO DOLLY:
This stage has witnessed an increased contribution by secular and legal thinkers in the ongoing debate about cloning, unlike earlier stages that were largely dominated by theological thinkers. In the middle of the 1980s, a presidential ... It has been albert for Sept. » Blog Archive » If you like to give ...
When the cloning debate usurped the front pages of popular newspapers, we SF Fans or Slans for short did not see any ideas or ethical conundrums debated there that had not been, in stories, debated from every angle. ... final exam
scientists are also not able to publish any of their work unless it is all legal and their procedures are described in great detail. i don’t think the movie “the island,” where clones are manufactured in case the donor needs organs or ... reelect president bush for the 2nd term: evidence & proofs
we can all see the issues involved in the cloning debate, which go much deeper than religion; the real debate has to do with evolutions process of a self-replicating organic machine, human beings, and the future of science and the ... LifeSiteNews.com - Thursday October 16, 2008
CANBERRA, Australia, October 16, 2008 (LifeSiteNews.com) - The Australian Senate has passed a bill that grants unmarried long-term couples, including homosexual couples, the same legal process provided to divorcing married couples. ... Cant Get There From Here
No convening legal authority.? If something goes wrong at home or a bill needs to be paid, Harry Truman summed it up best when he said, ?The buck stops here.? The buck always stops with you. You need to ?Walk softly and carry a big ... CellNEWS_Clash of the sentiments or reason: The cloning debate in ...
With these prospects at hand, the medical research community, the public who want relief from many severe ailments, and even ethicists discussing the necessity of legal groundwork surrounding cloning work on human cells, should worry. ... Transhumanism still at the crossroads
This has kept me actively involved in the science fiction field, which has likely provoked sighs and raised eyebrows from my staider colleagues in academia and legal practice. Yet this is nothing compared to the social stigma of being ... |
|
|
|
