|
Home::Chris Taylor
The Internet and the Library
Author : Sam Vaknin
"In this digital age, the custodians of published works are at the center of a global copyright controversy that casts them as villains simply for doing their job: letting people borrow books for free."
(ZDNet quoted by "Publisher's Lunch on July 13, 2001)
It is amazing that the traditional archivists of human knowledge - the libraries - failed so spectacularly to ride the tiger of the Internet, that epitome and apex of knowledge creation and distribution. At first, libraries, the inertial repositories of printed matter, were overwhelmed by the rapid pace of technology and by the ephemeral and anarchic content it spawned. They were reduced to providing access to dull card catalogues and unimaginative collections of web links. The more daring added online exhibits and digitized collections. A typical library web site is still comprised of static representations of the library's physical assets and a few quasi-interactive services.
This tendency - by both publishers and libraries - to inadequately and inappropriately pour old wine into new vessels is what caused the recent furor over e-books.
The lending of e-books to patrons appears to be a natural extension of the classical role of libraries: physical book lending. Libraries sought also to extend their archival functions to e-books. But librarians failed to grasp the essential and substantive differences between the two formats. E-books can be easily, stealthily, and cheaply copied, for instance. Copyright violations are a real and present danger with e-books. Moreover, e-books are not a tangible product. "Lending" an e-book - is tantamount to copying an e-book. In other words, e-books are not books at all. They are software products. Libraries have pioneered digital collections (as they have other information technologies throughout history) and are still the main promoters of e-publishing. But now they are at risk of becoming piracy portals.
Solutions are, appropriately, being borrowed from the software industry. NetLibrary has lately granted multiple user licences to a university library system. Such licences allow for unlimited access and are priced according to the number of the library's patrons, or the number of its reading devices and terminals. Another possibility is to implement the shareware model - a trial period followed by a purchase option or an expiration, a-la Rosetta's expiring e-book.
Distributor Baker & Taylor have unveiled at the recent ALA a prototype e-book distribution system jointly developed by ibooks and Digital Owl. It will be sold to libraries by B&T's Informata division and Reciprocal.
The annual subscription for use of the digital library comprises "a catalog of digital content, brandable pages and web based tools for each participating library to customize for their patrons. Patrons of participating libraries will then be able to browse digital content online, or download and check out the content they are most interested in. Content may be checked out for an extended period of time set by each library, including checking out eBooks from home." Still, it seems that B&T's approach is heavily influenced by software licencing ("one copy one use").
But, there is an underlying, fundamental incompatibility between the Internet and the library. They are competitors. One vitiates the other. Free Internet access and e-book reading devices in libraries notwithstanding - the Internet, unless harnessed and integrated by libraries, threatens their very existence by depriving them of patrons. Libraries, in turn, threaten the budding software industry we, misleadingly, call "e-publishing".
There are major operational and philosophical differences between physical and virtual libraries. The former are based on the tried and proven technology of print. The latter on the chaos we know as cyberspace and on user-averse technologies developed by geeks and nerds, rather than by marketers, users, and librarians.
Physical libraries enjoy great advantages, not the least being their habit-forming head start (2,500 years of first mover advantage). Libraries are hubs of social interaction and entertainment (the way cinemas used to be). Libraries have catered to users' reference needs in reference centres for centuries (and, lately, through Selective Dissemination of Information, or SDI). The war is by no means decided. "Progress" may yet consist of the assimilation of hi-tech gadgets by lo-tech libraries. It may turn out to be convergence at its best, as librarians become computer savvy - and computer types create knowledge and disseminate it.
About the Author
Sam Vaknin is the author of Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited and After the Rain - How the West Lost the East. He is a columnist for Central Europe Review, United Press International (UPI) and eBookWeb and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory, Suite101 and searcheurope.com.
Visit Sam's Web site at http://samvak.tripod.com
Related articles
|
More related feeds |
Interview with Author of “Travelling Europe”
Start reading as much as you can: use free resources like the internet and the library rather than spending money on new books. If you know someone who’s travelled invest in taking them out for a drink…and take notes! ...f » Blog Archive » discovery on the network level - it’s too messy ...
That story happened long enough ago that we we were still talking about “the Internet” and “the library” as if they were two different things. So “lots of libraries” was way more of “the world of information” than was our one library, ... Check out the library’s brand new computers
Library staff say the new terminals will give patrons faster access to word processing software, the Internet and the library’s Libary2Go program, which allows patrons to download audio books and more for free. ADVERTISEMENTS ... Science Library Pad: my review of The Long Tail
Anderson's ideas are certainly popular with both the Internet and the library (and the Internet library :) crowd. for example see my previous posts Long Tail book and ALA presentation and TypePad + Long Tail. ... LIS 569: History of American librarianship: Public Libraries Vs ...
The study wanted to investigate the relationship between the Internet and the library in terms of information seeking individuals. They saw that many services which the library offered were also offered by the Internet, and they wanted ... On Moving Toward Vegetarianism: Teenagers : TreeHugger
As I was very young, I had no idea there was so much info about the subject gathered on the Internet and the library, and just kept eating potatoes and boiled veggies. As years have passed, I've read more about the subject and have a ... The Library of Babel: Imagining an Infinite Library Decades Before ...
An essay by James Grimmelmann remarks on the similarities between the Internet and The Library of Babel, but there are many things to be done to make that comparison apt. ILTA | Available Positions
Ability to use research tools available through the internet and the library. Boolean logic and strong researching skills will be needed. Proofreading level of attention to detail required. Must be very detail oriented with the focus to ... How to Find Scholarships
The most popular source of information on scholarships are the Internet and the library. The internet allows you to look for a large amount of information within a relatively short period of time. You can look for scholarships from a ... Thoughts on the Internet’s Founding Myths « Narcissism and ...
The few credible sources of reliable information have long been drowned in a cacophony of fakes and phonies or gone out of business. It is a sad mockery of the idea of progress. The more texts we make available online, the more research ... |
|
|
